Why Don't We Do Things That Just Make Sense?
Why Don't We Do Things That Just Make Sense?
People and organizations often fail to pursue apparently sensible improvements because recognizing a better outcome does not guarantee that everyone involved has sufficient reason to help produce it. Incentives, transition costs, cognitive biases, competing objectives, and collective action problems can all preserve behavior that appears irrational from the outside.
That changes how resistance should be diagnosed. If the obstacle is misunderstanding, better information may help. If someone already understands the benefits but personally absorbs the cost, another explanation probably will not.
Different People Can Rationally Want Different Things
Imagine a company considering automation that could save thousands of employee hours each year. The executive sponsor sees lower operating costs, while the department manager may see reduced headcount and authority. Employees see job uncertainty, IT inherits technical risks, and finance sees the upfront investment.
Everyone can agree that the automation works. The disagreement concerns what each person is trying to protect.
This is why many organizational problems are better understood as alignment problems than intelligence problems. The same decision can look excellent from one objective and unattractive from another.
Incentives Often Speak Louder Than Goals
Organizations frequently tell people to pursue one objective while materially rewarding something else. A company encourages innovation but punishes failed experiments. A service department promotes customer satisfaction while evaluating employees mainly on call duration. A school celebrates learning while attaching the most important rewards to test performance.
The formal message describes what leaders hope people will do. The incentive system determines what behavior affects pay, promotion, workload, status, and security.
When those messages conflict, behavior usually follows the consequences. More communication does not repair a reward system pointing in the opposite direction.
People Do Not See the Same Problem
Different professional backgrounds also shape perception. Dearborn and Simon's research on executive judgment showed that executives from different departments emphasized different issues when examining the same business case.
Experience teaches us which signals deserve attention. Finance notices return and cash flow. Sales notices customer behavior. Operations sees process constraints. Legal notices exposure.
None of these perspectives is complete. What looks like common sense often reflects expertise that another person does not share.
A useful response to disagreement is therefore to ask what each participant is seeing rather than assuming somebody simply failed to understand.
Immediate Rewards Compete With Future Benefits
Misalignment also happens within individuals. People know that exercise, sleep, and saving money benefit them over time, yet immediate rewards frequently win.
The plan to exercise tomorrow morning may feel completely sensible the night before. When the alarm sounds, staying in bed becomes immediate while most benefits of exercise remain distant.
Present bias helps explain that shift. Commitment devices such as automatic savings, scheduled workouts, or accountability partners work because they alter the decision environment rather than merely reminding us of information we already know.
The problem is not always knowledge. Sometimes the present version of us has different incentives from the future version.
The Status Quo Gets Special Treatment
Existing arrangements have another advantage: they do not usually need to win a new decision every day.
Suppose a company uses outdated software. Replacing it requires budget approval, migration planning, training, downtime, and someone willing to own the implementation risk. Keeping the current system allows operations to continue without any visible transition decision.
The old system has costs too, but those costs have become normal. They are embedded in routine operations rather than presented as a proposal requiring approval.
Switching costs can be real, so staying put is not automatically irrational. A useful test is whether the organization would deliberately choose the existing arrangement if it were starting from scratch today.
Shared Interests Still Do Not Guarantee Action
Some problems survive even when everybody agrees about the outcome.
Imagine ten neighboring businesses that would all benefit from better street lighting, landscaping, and signage. Every owner supports the idea because the improved area would attract more customers.
Each owner would also prefer that somebody else pay.
If everyone follows that individual incentive, the improvement never happens. The group has a shared objective but no mechanism for producing the shared contribution.
This is the free-rider problem. The solution is not another explanation of why the improvement would help. The solution is a structure that distributes costs and establishes commitments.
Transition Costs Can Make the Destination Look Easier Than It Is
Another reason obvious changes fail is that proposals often compare the current state with an ideal future while ignoring the path between them.
A new system may be cheaper once fully implemented. Migration may still require six months of disruption. A new organization design may improve efficiency eventually while damaging customer service during the transition.
Those costs do not prove the change is wrong. They are part of the actual decision.
An improvement can seem obvious when the analysis counts the destination but excludes the journey.
Match the Intervention to the Obstacle
Different failures require different responses. Competing objectives require clearer shared priorities. Misaligned incentives require different rewards and consequences. Limited perspective requires additional viewpoints. Present bias may require commitment devices, while status quo bias calls for reevaluating the existing arrangement as critically as the proposed one.
Implementation costs require a better transition plan. Collective action problems require shared obligations or mechanisms for contribution.
The intervention should operate at the same level as the obstacle.
This is why the sentence “They just need to understand” is often inadequate. Understanding is one mechanism among several.
Reverse the Question
When inefficient behavior persists, assume temporarily that it serves some purpose.
Who benefits from the current arrangement? Who avoids risk? Who would lose authority, security, money, or convenience if the change occurred? Which cost has the proposed solution ignored?
Those questions turn frustration into diagnosis.
The next time something seems so sensible that its absence appears absurd, resist stopping at “Why aren't they doing this?”
Ask instead:
What makes not doing it make sense?
Understanding why something makes sense is only half the problem. Understanding why it isn't happening is the other half.

Comments
Post a Comment