Which of Your Advantages Are Real, and Which Are Just Momentum?
Which of Your Advantages Are Real, and Which Are Just Momentum?
How to separate lasting strengths from lucky streaks before they run out
Big-picture framing
When you ask, “Which of my advantages are real, and which are just momentum?”, you’re really asking how much of your success is built on muscle versus a moving sidewalk. Real advantages are strengths you can explain, reproduce, and rely on; momentum is the leftover push from timing, trends, or past decisions. In this piece, we’ll explore how to tell the difference and why, sometimes, it’s actually rational to ride momentum hard even if it’s short-lived. The goal is to get clear on what you can keep building on, what you can consciously exploit, and what could vanish the moment the environment shifts.
The Difference Between Real Advantages and Momentum
Think of riding a bike downhill. For a while, it feels like you’re incredibly strong—but are you fast because of your legs, or the slope?
Real advantages are like strong legs:
- You built them deliberately
- You can use them on any road
- They still matter even when conditions change
Momentum is the downhill stretch:
- It feels like power, but it’s borrowed from the environment
- It fades when the slope flattens
- You can’t easily recreate it on command
A quick test for any supposed advantage:
- Causality: Can you point to a specific capability, system, or behavior that creates this advantage?
- Repeatability: Could you use this advantage to win again in a different market, role, or context?
- Resilience: If technology, rules, or competitors changed, would this still help you?
If you can’t answer “yes” to at least two, you’re probably looking at momentum dressed up as an advantage.
How Momentum Pretends to Be an Advantage
Momentum is sneaky because it shows up in the same places real advantages do: revenue, promotions, market share, reputation.
Common signs you’re mostly riding momentum:
- You can’t explain it clearly.
“We’ve just always been good at this” is a red flag. Real advantages have a story: choices, practices, tradeoffs. - It depended heavily on timing.
You were early to a platform, lucky with a boss, first to a region. Helpful, yes—repeatable, not necessarily. - Customers or stakeholders are ‘fine,’ not thrilled.
People stay with you because switching is annoying, not because you’re clearly better. - Recreating it sounds impossible.
If you moved companies, changed markets, or started over, you don’t know how you’d replicate the “advantage.”
Momentum isn’t bad. The danger is assuming it will last forever and planning as if the road will always slope in your favor.
Real-World Example: A “Star” Product Manager
Picture a product manager, Maya, with a reputation as a “rock star.” She’s led several successful launches at a well-known brand. Her perceived advantages:
- She “always ships winning features”
- Leadership “trusts her gut”
- Her products “naturally gain traction”
When Maya considers switching to a startup, she audits her strengths:
- Likely real advantages
- She runs tight discovery interviews and synthesizes insights clearly
- She builds strong trust with engineering
- She writes simple product narratives that align stakeholders
- Likely momentum
- The brand’s huge audience ensured adoption
- A strong growth team amplified her launches
- A mature design system made everything look polished
She realizes: part of her success was the “downhill slope” of brand, channels, and support teams. But her real advantages are portable:
- Customer discovery skill
- Cross-functional trust
- Clear communication
That clarity lets her talk honestly about what she brings with her—and where she’s been boosted by momentum she’d need to rebuild elsewhere.
When It’s Rational to Ride Momentum Hard
Here’s the counterpoint: sometimes the smartest move is to lean into momentum, knowing full well it won’t last.
Riding momentum can be rational when:
- The window is clearly short-lived.
A hype-driven channel, a temporary regulation, a fad product you know won’t be hot in three years. - The edge can’t be made durable.
Your advantage depends on a one-off partnership, a novelty, or exclusive access that will inevitably end. - The payback time for new “muscles” is longer than the window.
If it takes 3–5 years to build a deep capability and the window is 12–18 months, long-term investment won’t pay back for this game. - You need resources for your next act.
Momentum can be a cash, data, or attention generator that funds the real advantages you’ll build later.
The key is honesty: “We’re surfing this wave on purpose, and we don’t expect it to last.” That’s very different from confusing a sprint with a permanent strategy.
Turning Momentum into Real Advantage
You don’t have to shame momentum or pretend it isn’t there. You can harvest it:
- Name your momentum clearly
- “We’re benefiting from being early.”
- “Our boss’s network is a huge part of this.”
- “This regulation currently protects us.”
- Decide what muscles to build while the slope helps
Even if the focus is short-term, you can skim off energy to invest in durable capabilities like:- Deep customer understanding
- Operational excellence
- Distinctive brand and story
- Talent density and learning culture
- Run ‘what if it vanished?’ drills
- “If this tailwind disappeared in two years, what would we wish we’d built?”
- Choose your mix explicitly
- “For this opportunity, we’ll spend 70% effort riding momentum, 30% building muscles for what comes next.”
The goal isn’t to have zero momentum. It’s to ensure that when the ground shifts, you’ve got enough muscle—skills, processes, relationships, and insight—to keep moving, not just enough slope to keep coasting.
Bringing It All Together
The core move is simple but uncomfortable: treat your supposed strengths as hypotheses, not facts. Test each one: Is it causal, repeatable, and resilient—or just historical momentum that hasn’t been challenged yet? At the same time, admit there are moments when it’s rational to ride momentum hard, as long as you’re deliberate about the time horizon and the risks.
If you want to keep practicing questions like this—the kind that quietly upgrade how you think about strategy and advantage—follow QuestionClass’s Question-a-Day at questionclass.com and build a daily habit of sharper inquiry.
Bookmarked for You
Here are a few books that deepen the themes behind real vs. momentum-based advantages:
Good Strategy/Bad Strategy by Richard Rumelt – A clear-eyed look at what actually counts as strategy, and how to distinguish real advantage from wishful slogans.
The Innovator’s Dilemma by Clayton M. Christensen – A classic on how yesterday’s strengths become today’s vulnerabilities when disruption arrives.
The End of Competitive Advantage by Rita Gunther McGrath – Argues that most advantages are now transient and shows how to compete through continual renewal.
QuestionStrings to Practice
“QuestionStrings are deliberately ordered sequences of questions in which each answer fuels the next, creating a compounding ladder of insight that drives progressively deeper understanding. What to do now: use this to audit your strengths—personally or as a team—and decide what to double down on, what to harvest, and what to reinvent.”
Muscle vs. Momentum String
For when you want to separate true advantages from a lucky slope:
“What are the top three ‘advantages’ I believe I (or we) have right now?” →
“For each one, what specific skills, systems, or habits actually create this?” →
“If I changed companies, roles, or markets, which of these would still show up?” →
“What external conditions (timing, trends, people, brand) are currently boosting me?” →
“Given all that, which advantage should I strengthen, and which momentum should I ride consciously while it lasts?”
Try running this in a journal, a team retro, or a strategy offsite. Capture the answers, then pick one real advantage to train and one momentum wave to surf deliberately.
Seeing clearly which advantages are real and which are just momentum is one of the fastest ways to design a future you can actually control—not just ride.
Comments
Post a Comment