Why Doesn’t the Internet Work as Intended?

Why Doesn’t the Internet Work as Intended?

February 7, 2025|Digital Transformation, Ethics, Innovation, Psychology, Question a Day, Social Responsibility, Strategy

Question-a-Day

Why the Internet Feels Broken (and How to Fix It)

The internet was meant to be a free-flowing exchange of knowledge and connection. Instead, we got misinformation, privacy invasions, and endless pop-up ads. Here’s why the internet feels broken—and how we can fix it.

The internet was born out of a grand vision: an open, limitless space for sharing knowledge, fostering collaboration, and connecting the world. What we got was… well, kind of that—plus phishing scams, endless pop-up ads, and conspiracy theories about pigeons being government drones.

So, why does the internet feel so far removed from its original ideal? The answer lies in a mix of technical limitations, corporate greed, and, let’s be honest, human nature. Here’s a closer look at why the internet doesn’t always work as intended—and what we can do to untangle its problems.

1. The Internet Wasn’t Designed for Today’s Scale

When the internet was conceived, its creators likely didn’t imagine billions of people streaming 4K videos, sharing TikToks, and collectively Googling “Why is my Wi-Fi slow?” all at once. The infrastructure simply wasn’t built for this level of demand.

• Bandwidth Crunch: Internet infrastructure hasn’t kept up with modern usage, especially in rural or underserved areas where high-speed broadband is still a luxury.
• Congestion Woes: Even in well-connected regions, peak usage times can lead to buffering nightmares.
• Outdated Protocols: Many of the internet’s core protocols were designed decades ago, long before cybersecurity, social media, or video streaming were even concepts.

💡 Tech Truth: The internet wasn’t broken by design—it just didn’t plan to babysit 5 billion users.

2. Corporate Control vs. Public Interest

Much of the internet is no longer a neutral, open space. Instead, it’s increasingly dominated by corporations that prioritize profit over user experience.

• Ad-Driven Models: Most platforms monetize through advertising, leading to invasive data tracking, clickbait content, and features designed to keep you endlessly scrolling.
• Walled Gardens: Tech giants like Facebook, Apple, and Google create closed ecosystems that lock users in, limiting true competition and interoperability.
• Net Neutrality Battles: Without strong net neutrality protections, ISPs can throttle speeds, prioritize paying companies, and effectively gatekeep parts of the internet.

💭 Observation: The internet was supposed to democratize access, but somehow, it created a digital aristocracy instead.

3. Misinformation and Digital Chaos

The internet promised to make the world smarter. Instead, it often makes us angrier, more divided, and occasionally convinced that drinking bleach is a miracle cure.

• Algorithmic Amplification: Social media platforms prioritize engagement, meaning sensational or divisive content spreads faster—even when it’s false.
• Echo Chambers: People naturally gravitate toward information that confirms their biases, creating digital bubbles that reinforce misinformation.
• Trolling and Toxicity: Anonymous platforms embolden bad actors, turning civil discourse into virtual shouting matches.

🤯 Thought Experiment: Imagine a library where books screamed at you and occasionally lied—congratulations, you’ve imagined the internet.

4. Privacy? What Privacy?

The early architects of the internet didn’t prioritize privacy because they didn’t anticipate how far corporations and governments would go to exploit it.

• Data Exploitation: Every click, search, and “like” is tracked, sold, and used to target you with ads—or worse, manipulate your behavior.
• Weak Security Foundations: Legacy internet protocols weren’t designed to handle today’s complex cybersecurity threats.
• Mass Surveillance: Governments and corporations alike use the internet to monitor users, often without transparency or accountability.

😬 Modern Dilemma: On the internet, privacy isn’t dead—it’s a luxury item sold to the highest bidder.

5. Human Behavior: The Ultimate Wild Card

Here’s the thing: the internet works exactly as intended—until humans get involved.

• Over-Sharing: Users casually post personal data, making themselves easy targets for scams and identity theft.
• Addiction by Design: Platforms use psychological tricks (like infinite scrolling and dopamine rewards) to keep us glued to our screens.
• Digital Inequality: While some scroll TikTok on 5G networks, others still struggle with dial-up speeds or no access at all.

🤷 Reality Check: The internet’s biggest flaw isn’t its code—it’s the unpredictable, imperfect humans who use it.

6. Complex Systems, Fragile Foundations

The internet is a patchwork of networks, protocols, and devices, making it inherently fragile.

• Software Glitches: Even a tiny coding error can cause massive outages (remember when Facebook went offline in 2021?).
• Infrastructure Bottlenecks: Outdated hardware and underfunded networks can’t keep up with growing demands.
• Interoperability Issues: Different platforms and technologies often clash, creating inefficiencies and vulnerabilities.

🛠 Fun Fact: The internet is held together by a mix of genius engineering, blind optimism, and digital duct tape.

How Can We Fix the Internet?

While the internet’s problems are complex, there are practical steps that can help it work more like the utopian vision we were promised:

1. Strengthen Net Neutrality Protections

Advocate for laws that ensure all online traffic is treated equally, without giving preference to the highest bidder.

2. Enforce Data Privacy Regulations

Support stronger global privacy standards like GDPR and demand transparency from tech companies.

3. Promote Digital Literacy

Teach people how to spot misinformation, secure their data, and navigate the web responsibly.

4. Invest in Infrastructure

Governments and private organizations must fund faster, more reliable internet for underserved areas.

5. Build Ethical Platforms

Push for technologies that prioritize user well-being over addictive design or ad revenue.

Conclusion: The Internet’s Not Broken, Just Misaligned

The internet is a remarkable invention, but it often feels like it’s betraying its promise because it reflects our imperfections as much as our ingenuity. Fixing it requires systemic changes, better infrastructure, and a collective commitment to prioritizing public interest over profits.

Until then, keep your antivirus software updated and maybe think twice before engaging with that troll in the comments.

Want to Ask Smarter Questions About the Internet and Beyond?

Follow Question-a-Day and start your journey here.